Old Bardstown

79 Disappointing

A lot of Willett fans are going to be either kidding themselves or highly disappointed in the first bourbon released by Willett from their new distillery. This tastes under-aged with a strange combination of ethanol and rubber on the center of the palate.

What it isold-bardstown-bottled-in-bon002

Rarely has a sub $25 release of a new bourbon been as anticipated or as watched as this Old Bardstown Bottled in Bond. Why? Simple. It’s the first bourbon distilled at the new Willett distillery to be bottled and sold. It’s age-stated at 4 years, and as a bonded bourbon, is 100 proof. Past that, there isn’t much information yet on the mash bill or the entry proof or anything like that. But that’s okay, because we’re most interested in what’s in the bottle and how it tastes. This was released just a few days ago at the Willett Gift Shop in Bardstown at a price of $21.99.


I find it interesting that, given Willett’s long history with Heaven Hill, that they chose a bottled in bond format (which heaven Hill produces in quite a few formats), and chose a bottle that reminds me very much of the Evan Williams and Heaven Hill bonded bourbons. So to make a long story short, it LOOKS like a bottled in bond bourbon. At $22, it’s not a particularly eye catching packaging, and has a plastic screw top. But it works.


This is surprisingly dark for a four year old bourbon, and borders on brown rather than amber.


Sticky sweet with tons of molasses and caramel and a hint of anise/licorice.


This starts off true to the nose with a rush of sweet caramel and oak on tip of the tongue, but it definitely devolves quickly into a strange combination of black licorice and burnt rubber. Yeah, burnt rubber. It rounds out with a lot of young corn followed by oak.


The weird licorice and rubber sensation continues after the swallow until it morphs into an ethanol/white dog sensation with lots of young corn and a substantial amount of oak at the tail end.



Something isn’t working here, and that’s disappointing. If there is any company the bourbon buying public WANTS to succeed, it’s Willett. Their sourced Family Estate bourbons and ryes are nearly as desirable as a lot of very limited supply highly sought after bourbons from big-time distilleries. But they’re missing the mark with this distillate. I had the opportunity to try their white dog about 9 months ago, and some of the same problems seemed to permeate it as well. The ethanol character leads me to believe this will be a much better whiskey at 6 years than 4, but when I added water to this, it certainly didn’t dilute the tire rubber flavors. If anything, it amplified it.  I tried hard to convince myself it was me, not the whiskey.  I even trashed the first set of notes I took, thinking it had to be something I ate that affected my palate and came back to it the next night.  And the next.  It wasn’t something I ate.  It was the whiskey.

glencairn-amazonThere will be a lot of Willett fans who aren’t happy with this review. I get that. I’m not happy because, all in all, I’m a pretty big Willett fan. But I have to be honest in my assessments or there’s no point in this blog at all. While this is drinkable, I suppose, it’s inferior to a lot of other bonded bourbons that can be had on the shelves for half its cost. Heaven Hill 6 year, Evan Williams, Jim Beam, and Very Old Barton all have better bonded bourbons on the shelf right now that are at least the same price, and in some cases closer to $10 than $20. And they’re all better.

I’m really pulling for Willett. There was a time when I felt they could do no wrong with their barrel picks. They’re new to the distilling game, so maybe time will mellow out this whiskey. Until then, I can’t recommend it.

ModernThirst.com Score: 79 out of 100 points.

What does this score mean?

Facebook Comments

About Author

Bill is the Co-Founder, Editor-in Chief, and official Bourbon-o-Phile for ModernThirst.com, and Founder and Chief Blending Officer for Four Gate Whiskey Company. He is a native of Louisville, KY in the heart of Bourbon Country. He attended the University of Kentucky in the mid to late 1990s. He has also been published on Liquor.com. He has conducted various bourbon and whiskey tastings in cities across the country, and consulted for multiple national labels. He is married with two daughters, and lives in east Louisville. You can follow him on Facebook and Twitter @BillStraub and email him at Bill@ModernThirst.com.


  1. I tried their 4 year “family estate” bourbon back when it was released in March.

    I immediately ignored it and bought the 3 year rye.
    Willett makes wonderful ryes, but I have officially written off their bourbon (both their own, and the Beam sourced stuff that tastes like death & peanuts).
    I hope they get it together or put more focus into the ryes.

  2. I really think there is some batch variation. The bottle I just got at the distillery tasted much like their 3 year rye with mint notes but a strong root beer characteristic. These notes continued with some shortbread and corn sweetness on the palate. Not my favorite, but nothing like you described.

  3. Back in the 60’s when the original Willett Distillery bottled Old Bardstown , it was excellent,but the new batch does measure up to that Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey that I enjoyed in high school.

  4. Jonathan Kiviniemi on

    I strongly disagree, as do many others. This does seem to be a polarizing bottle, but I think for the money it’s solid, and I’ll gladly drink it over other options in a similar price range.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.